These Secret Santa Gifts Look Pricier Than They Are (2024)

While Secret Santa and white elephant gift exchanges are all about having fun and getting in the holiday spirit, sometimes it can be straight-up stressful to pick out a decent gift. Like, you don't want to drop a lot of money, and it can also be sort of awkward depending on who you're buying for, especially if it's a mutual friend, acquaintance, or coworker you may not know very well.

It's also way too easy to procrastinate, which is why you're getting your options in order now. Keep a few of the funny, personal, and affordable gifts below on-hand now so you're not rushing to buy something from a gas station on the way to the office holiday party.

Keep reading for all the best Secret Santa gift ideas to give in 2023. Bonus: They're almost all under $25, which means all the gifts below also make great stocking stuffers (or, you know, affordable presents for yourself—you deserve it!).

If your giftee enjoys meditating and practicing yoga, these wooden dice will help add spontaneity to their daily routine. Plus, it comes with an instructional booklet that’s easy for people of all skill levels to understand.

This stub organizer is perfect for that concert-going friend who has a ton of tickets collecting dust in a random box or drawer. It even comes with a large back pocket to store other special keepsakes, and a small notes section on each page so they can reflect on the experience.

If your Secret Santa is a superstitious sports fan, this gift will become a major part of their pre-game ritual. With several football and baseball teams available to purchase, too (think: the Eagles, Cowboys, and Yankees), they might just secure a win thanks to this unique candle.

Perfume discovery sets are a great way to find the perfect scent. With this particular collection, your recipient can try five long-lasting fragrances that are vegan, hypoallergenic, and sustainably sourced.

Help your Secret Santa take their game night to the next level with this music card set full of classic hip-hop and R&B categories. They’re practically guaranteed to have endless fun.

Whether your coworker has been crocheting for years or just picked it up as a new hobby, they’ll love this informative book that’s chock-full of expert advice on everything there is to know about the craft.

Got a gamer on your hands? With more than 6,000 five-star reviews, you can’t go wrong with this headset that’s super affordable and compatible with a variety of gaming platforms, including Xbox and PS5.

Gift this sleek belt to the runner in your life who’s always up early for a morning jog. It’s lightweight, adjustable, and comes in several different shades. Simply pick their favorite color and add to your cart.

Your Secret Santa will definitely stand out in the kitchen with this personalized apron. It has everything they’ll need: two front pockets, extra long waist ties, and an adjustable neck strap.

This grown-up version of playdough will help your giftee feel more relaxed at the end of a long, tiring day. Infused with essential oils for aromatherapy, they can even keep it at their desk whenever they need a few minutes to calm their mind.

The best gifts are both personal and practical, so your purse-obsessed friend will love using this hilarious mug in the morning while they peruse online for their next favorite handbag.

This unique collage kit features 63 mini art prints of America’s national parks. Rather than checking off boxes on their notes app bucket list, your nature-loving recipient can paste up an illustration each time they visit a national park. They’ll have a cool gallery wall in their home office in no time.

For a pet parent, why not surprise them with a stunning custom portrait of their furbaby? They’ll receive a super high-quality image that looks way more expensive than it actually is.

If your coworker is always losing their spectacles, they’ll appreciate this handmade wooden eyeglass holder. This gift will make the perfect addition to their desk or nightstand, too.

For an astrology lover who’s in need of some serious R&R, these vanilla rose-scented candles can help them decompress. Each one is handmade with natural soy wax and essential oils, and burns for over 50 hours.

An ice cream mood can strike at any time no matter the weather, so prepare your pal with this electric ice cream maker that'll churn up a pint with the touch of one simple button. They'll never know you just spent $21.

Face it: You know the cozy gift is always a fan fave. Find out your Secret Santa's favorite color, and gift them this fuzzy fleece throw. It comes in tons of different shades and has over 100,000 reviews on Amazon—'nuff said.

If you know your boss' office is super dry, they'll love you for gifting them this super cute mini cactus humidifier. Hey, get one for yourself while you're at it.

If your Secret Santa always has a hair tie around their wrist, upgrade that situation ASAP with these cute bracelet hair ties that double as jewelry.

A spa day may be out of your budget, but this cooling gel eye mask filled with lavender and flax seeds will definitely help your recipient de-stress during the hectic holidays.